Hog Dog Mike...
what can you say about the legendary Elhew line of English pointers and the original man behind them, Bob Wehle? I have been rather fascinated with his abilities as a promoter and breeder of some of his legendary dogs of yesteryear...I know he had the money to hunt and import dogs and to breed the ultimate English Pointers from what I have read and heard...I do know they were hard hunting and some of the most beautiful pointers I ever saw...I remember seeing 8 week old puppy pictures of some of these pups pointing bird wings...natural pointing and birdie instincts...
you having quite a bit of field trial experience so if you don't mind I would like to hear your thoughts on what so many doogers were saying back in the 1970's and 1980's about the field trials ruining the hunting dogs...this was coming from the hunters that did not field trial...I reckon the bottom line is that the field trialers were breeding to win and not worry so much about anything else...
What I remember is the coon hunters were saying the hounds are passing up good tracks to find a smoking hot track...also saying the dogs were ranging too far and hunting for themselves...
The retiever folks were saying that the field trial dogs were high strung and hard headed...had to keep a tight rein on them and will tear up the back yard if left unsupervised...did not double as pets like a hunting lab etc...etc...
The bird dog hunters were saying the field trials were ruining the dogs...especially the English pointers...they hunt for themselves it was said and you could not walk hunt behind them etc...etc...
It seems that about that time the German Short Hair became more popular because they were bred to have a strong hunting instinct yet were closer ranging dogs...hunting with or for the hunter...
These are some of the things I read and heard back in those days that folks were writing and saying...I don't hear much about it anymore...
so...with your vast experience as a field trialer and dog man, what are your thoughts on what I have written? I think it would be interesting and educational especially for the younger readers...thanks...
No problem. Here is the way the deal worked. Robert G. Whele turned his name around basackwards and named his kennel Elhew. He was from New York but also had a place in the south east. He wrote a book on bird dog training (Wing and Shot) and lots of folks swore by Elhew dogs. I got the book )(in the 70s), read it, and thought that I had it all figured out. All you have to do is go buy a Elhew dog and you were set. According to the writings they almost broke them selves, would out point, out back, out find, out everything anything coming down the pike. You have to actually buy a dog from his kennel to put the Elhew name in front on your dogs pedigree. Example you could not name a dog Elhew Jake but could name it Murphy's Elhew Jake.
I found a rich guy in Dallas that had several dogs he bought from Whele. I bought one and my buddy bought one. In my opinion they are inbred and you will see that if you run one, hunt one, or judge one. Mine would do pretty good for about 30 minutes and then she was going back to the truck and you could not stop her. My buddies dog was below average at best. Lots of them that I trained and observed seemed to be weak minded. Put some pressure on them and they would come apart. Not really tough dogs.
A friend of Whele named Dr. Alvin Nitchman ran a lot of dogs with Elhew blood but they were not the inbred ones. He did pretty good and had several winning dogs such as the Pork Roll dog. I had some good dogs that had a little Elhew blood in them way back.
The guys that bad mouth the field trial dogs probably got sold a cull from a field trailer. They will tell them Jake is a great hunting dog but just not run enough to be a field trial dog. Heard that many times and it is a dog jockey line. I personally owned dogs that won open horseback stakes, amateur horseback stakes, walking stakes, shoot to retrieve stakes, calcuttas, and could be hunted from foot, horse, truck, or 4 wheeler. Don't think a champion field trial dog cannot be handled on foot because they can.
When I finally got with some folks that really had some great dogs I ran mostly Rebel bred dogs. They were just smarter, tougher, and above all handled very well.
I don't know much about coon dogs. I will take a field trial retriever every single time. They are all great hunting dogs. If you doubt me go to an open trial and just watch the tests they have to do. Unbelievable. Any lab will tear up your yard because they are supposed to be in a kennel.
The bird hunter guys that bad mouth field trial pointers just watched the culls that got pawned off on hunters. I owned field trial dogs that I could hunt any kind of way you wanted to hunt. More than likely it was a dog that would not handle a lick. You can win a trial with all kinds of dogs but not a lost dog. A bird hunter organization had a trial that was a Calcutta. You had to buy braces once the names were drawn. All this money went into a pot and was awarded according to placements 1-5. Some serious money was involved. It was kind of a phony deal because it was only 6 minutes long and the deal was kill as many birds as quick as possible. I entered twice and won every placement and they banned me. The bird hunters got their plow cleaned by the field trial dogs. Most guys putting the bad mouth on field trial dogs has NEVER even seen a real one.
Here is the deal on German Shorthairs. If they are as good as pointers why do they have restricted field trials. Same thing on Britts, and Irish setters. I have seen exactly 1 GSP run in a horseback trial and it did not place. I saw one good one back in the 80s at a trial down around Waco.
The hunting camp on the King Ranch had 50 dogs that they owned @ 4,000.00 each. They had 35 dogs at the lease on the Jones ranch @ 4,000.00 each. My friend leased them another 35 dogs. We also had several field trial dogs and others that we were breaking and tuning up. The owners were oil men and money was no object.
All of the dogs were English Pointers with the exception of a hand full of English Setters. It takes a special dog to run in the heat day after day, in front of a truck, and they are better at it than any other. That is just a proven fact. I don't think a GSP has ever even qualified to run in the National Championship (there is only one) much less won it. Same thing for Britts and if a Irish Setter ever done it was a loooooooooooooooong time ago.
I have judged a few Irish Setters and ran in some of their trials. I ran in the open trial because all the others were restricted. To this day I have yet to EVER see any Irish Setter actually point a bird, hold it, and let you flush it. One friend of mine just loved them and wanted to bring the breed back. He spent enough money on them to buy a black land farm and if he ever won anything in open competition I never knew it.
There are a lot of GSPs up in South Dakota where I pheasant hunt. They seem to do well there and my guess is that they handle the cold weather better. I hunted them when hunting for Hungarian Partridges and they did OK. Not as fast as a pointer but got the job done.
We mainly use labs for pheasants with an occasional Springer Spaniel. They do an outstanding job and they are not the giant fat labs that you see around here. These dogs cover some ground when they hunt.